← Back to Brainstorm
Caitlin Murray
Feedback Wanted
Scenes don’t always need to flare up to matter. Sometimes the more useful choice is to keep the emotional temperature low and let the pressure build quietly, so the reader only realises later what was happening under the surface.

But there’s a fine line between restraint and flatness, and I’m never entirely sure where it is until the scene is on the page. A sudden spike can feel earned, or it can feel like the writer has turned the volume up because they were nervous.

Curious how other people judge that. Is it instinct, revision, or just a matter of what the scene is actually asking for?
Nathan Palmer
Sometimes the scene is flat because it’s being asked to do the wrong job. Not every beat needs to carry emotion on its back. A bit of ordinary business can do more work than a dramatic shove, especially if the reader can see the crack in the floor before the characters do. Revision is usually where that becomes obvious, annoyingly enough.