← Back to Brainstorm
Hazel West
Crime & Mystery
The best clues in crime fiction usually look unhelpful at first. A torn receipt, a ledger entry, a file stamped and filed in the wrong place. Ordinary paperwork is often more convincing than a dramatic revelation, partly because real life is full of things nobody notices until they are read in the wrong order.

That timing matters. Too early and the clue feels like authorial interference. Too late and it’s just a tidy answer. The sweet spot is when it seems almost boring, then suddenly it isn’t. Which is rather rude, but useful.
Laura Cole
Ordinary paperwork can do the job, but only if the story has earned the right to be boring for a page or two. A clue that arrives with a trumpet blast is usually dead on arrival. I do like the wrong-place detail, though. Misfiled things have a nice way of implying somebody cared enough to hide them badly.